Six structures in search of stability

Publication Date
Financial Markets Group Special Papers SP 236
Publication Authors

This paper analyses the proposition that adjusting structure can strengthen safety and therefore promote stability. It examines six proposals: Liikanen, Volcker, the US rule requiring foreign banking organisations (FBOs) to establish an intermediate holding company (IHC), depositor preference, bail-in plus total loss-absorbing capital (TLAC) and Vickers. Each endeavours to restructure banks along one or more of the following lines: activity, geography and/or creditor hierarchy. Only the creditor hierarchy approach holds the promise of enhancing financial stability, and the complete reordering (bail-in plus TLAC) is distinctly superior to the partial reordering implied by depositor preference. Indeed, bail-in plus TLAC opens the door to making banks resolvable. That in turn makes segregation by activity or by geography superfluous.

Download